0 items in Cart
Bay Goodman Pizza Logo
  • Home
  • Gallery
  • Menu
  • Order Online
  • 0 items in Cart
  • Home
  • Gallery
  • Menu
  • Order Online
Group Order Sign Up For Deals

Bay Goodman Pizza Online Ordering Menu

1687 MT HOPE AVE
ROCHESTER, NY 14620
(585) 442-6865
11:00 AM - 10:00 PM
Start your carryout or delivery order.
Check Availability
Menu Icon Legend

CUSTOM PIZZA/CALZONE
Small 12" Pizza 
$15.83+
Medium 14" Pizza 
$18.62+
Large 16" Pizza 
$20.69+
Sheet Pizza 
$25.88+
Calzones 
$15.83+
Cauliflower Crust 14" 
$21.72+

WINGS & FINGERS

Served with bleu cheese dressing.
Jumbo Wings 
$1.71+
Boneless Wings 
$7.75+
Chicken Fingers 
$13.44+
Wings & Side 
$11.33

SHAREABLES
Pizza Logs 
$9.62+
Mozzarella Sticks 
$9.62+
Loaded Fries w/ Bacon 
$9.30+
Bay Goodman Platter 
$18.93+
10 Jumbo Wings 
$15.41
1lb Boneless 
$13.34+
Onion Ring Basket 
$9.62
Loaded Fries 
$9.30
Loaded Skins 
$10.34

CLASSIC & SPECIALTY PIZZAS
Deluxe Pizza 
$20.65+
Garlic Garden 
$20.65+
Buffalo Chicken Pie Pizza 
$20.65+
Three Meat Pizza 
$20.65+
Elite Eight Pizza 
$20.65+
Pizza Napoli 
$20.65+
Pizza Divinci 
$20.65+
Pizza Sicillia 
$20.65+
Veggie Weggie Pizza 
$20.65+
Calzones 
$15.83+

SIDES
French Fries 
$6.10
House Salad Side 
$6.10
Macaroni Salad 
$6.10
Home Fries 
$6.10
Caesar Salad Side 
$6.10
House Made Chips 
$5.06
Garlic Knot 
$0.88
Garlic Knots 
$5.06
Onion Rings 
$6.10
Fresh Made Chips 
$6.10

Burgers
Rochester Burger 
$9.26+
All American Burger 
$9.26+
Bacon Cheeseburger 
$11.13+
My Way Burger 
$9.26+
Hamburger 
$8.23+

BEVERAGES
Can Soda 
Pepsi, Diet Pepsi, Mt Dew, Brisk Tea
$1.96
Coca Cola 2 Liter 
$4.13
Sprite 2 Liter 
$4.13
Bottle Water 
$1.96
2 Liter Diet Coke 
$4.13

PANINIS
Pizano Panini 
$13.34+
Wise Guy Panini 
$13.34+
Bambino Panini 
$13.34+
Margherita Panini 
$13.34+
The My Way Panini 
$13.34+
Garden Grill Panini 
$13.34

Great Plates

Served with choice of 2 sides.
Hamburger Plate 
$15.41+
Cheeseburger Plate 
$15.41+
Italian Sausage 
$15.41+
Chicken Finger 
$15.41+
Half Plate Chicken Finger  
$9.82+
Half Plate Hamburger Plate  
$9.82+
Half Plate Italian Sausage 
$9.82+
Half Plate Steak 
$8.79+
Steak Plate 
$15.41+

SALADS
House Salad 
$9.82+
Caesar Salad 
$10.86+
Mediterranian Salad 
$12.93+
Chopped Veggie Salad 
$11.89+

Hot Subs
Meatball Parmigiano Subub 
$0.00+
Buffalo Chicken Sub 
$0.00+
Goodman Delite Sub 
$0.00+
Steak In The Grass Sub 
$0.00+
The Capo Sub 
$0.00+
Great Steak Out Sub 
$0.00+
Chicken Parm Sub 
$0.00+
Bay Burger Sub 
$0.00+
My Way Cheese Steak Sub 
$0.00+

EXTRA SAUCES
Buffalo Medium Sauce 
$0.96
Buffalo Hot Sauce 
$0.96
Buffalo Mild Sauce 
$0.96
Country Sweet 
$0.96
BBQ Sauce 
$0.96
Bleu Cheese 
$0.96
Ranch Dressing 
$0.96
House Dressing 
$0.96
Marinara 
$0.96
Garlic Parm 
$0.96
Meat Hot Sauce 
$0.96
Sour Cream 
$0.96
8oz Meat Hot Sauce 
$7.19

Wraps
Garden Grill Wrap 
$13.34+
Buffalo Chicken Wrap 
$13.34+
Grilled Chicken Caesar Wrap 
$11.27+
Steak Artichoke & Mushroom Wrap 
$13.34+
Grilled Artichoke Chicken Wrap 
$13.34+

DESSERTS
Pizza Fritta 
$4.44
Brownie 
$6.10
Chocolate Chunk Cookie 
$3.09

Monday Free Topping
Monday Large 1 Toppng 
$18.62+

Weekender Special
Weekender Special 
$20.70+

Cold Subs
Old Fashioned Sub 
$6.95+
My Way Sub 
$6.95+
Italian Assorted Sub 
$6.95+
Your cart is empty.
Powered by Menufy © 2023
  • Accessibility
  • Terms
  • Help
  • Privacy
Loading, please wait.